Introduction to Mixture and Alligation for RRB Exams

If you are preparing for Indian Railway Recruitment Board (RRB) examinations such as RRB NTPC (CBT-1 and CBT-2), RRB Group D, RRB Technician Grade I, or RRB Technician Grade III, Mathematics is the section that can single-handedly decide your final merit rank. Among all arithmetic chapters, Mixture and Alligation stands out as one of the most versatile, high-scoring, and time-saving topics in the entire syllabus.

At first glance, many aspirants treat Mixture and Alligation as just another word-problem chapter involving milk, water, rice, or sugar. However, experienced railway exam toppers know a crucial secret: Alligation is not merely a chapter; it is a universal calculation shortcut. Once you master the rule of Alligation, you can solve complex questions from Averages, Percentage, Profit and Loss, Simple Interest, Ratio and Proportion, and even Time, Speed, and Distance in less than 20 seconds without writing lengthy algebraic equations.

In railway Computer Based Tests (CBTs), where every second matters and negative marking penalizes guesswork, knowing how to apply Alligation accurately gives you a massive competitive edge. In this complete guide, we will break down every concept from scratch, cover all essential formulas and shortcuts, solve exam-level problems step by step, highlight common traps, and provide practice questions with detailed solutions.

Topic Weightage and Importance

Before diving into formulas, let us understand how frequently Mixture and Alligation appears across different RRB examinations. Based on previous years' question papers from RRB NTPC, Group D, and Technician exams, questions from this topic appear in two ways: direct mixture problems (such as mixing liquids, alloys, or groceries, and replacement of liquids) and indirect application problems (where Alligation acts as the fastest method to solve Profit & Loss, Average, or Interest questions).

RRB Exam StageDirect QuestionsIndirect Application QuestionsDifficulty Level
RRB NTPC CBT-11 to 2 Questions2 to 3 QuestionsEasy to Moderate
RRB NTPC CBT-22 to 3 Questions2 to 3 QuestionsModerate to Tricky
RRB Group D1 to 2 Questions1 to 2 QuestionsEasy to Moderate
RRB Technician Grade I & III1 to 2 Questions1 to 2 QuestionsModerate

As shown in the table above, mastering this single topic directly impacts 3 to 5 marks in your exam paper. In RRB NTPC CBT-2 and Technician exams, questions involving successive removal and replacement as well as mixing two solutions of unequal concentrations are frequently tested. Securing full accuracy in these 3 to 5 questions can easily push your normalized score well above the cut-off.

Key Concepts and Formulas

To master Mixture and Alligation, you must first understand the clear distinction between the two terms and the mathematical logic behind the famous criss-cross rule.

1. What is a Mixture?

When two or more substances (liquids, solids, grains, metals, or solutions) of different prices, qualities, or concentrations are combined together, the resulting combination is called a Mixture. Mixtures are broadly categorized into two types:

  • Simple Mixture: When two different ingredients are mixed together (for example, mixing water with milk, or mixing Rs. 40/kg rice with Rs. 60/kg rice).
  • Compound Mixture: When two or more mixtures themselves are combined to form a new mixture (for example, mixing two vessels that already contain different ratios of milk and water).

2. What is Alligation?

Alligation is a rule or technique that enables us to find the ratio in which two or more ingredients at given prices or concentrations must be mixed together to produce a mixture of a desired price or concentration. It also helps us find the mean value (average price or concentration) of a mixture when the quantities or mixing ratio of the ingredients are known.

3. The Fundamental Rule of Alligation (Criss-Cross Method)

Suppose a cheaper ingredient with unit cost price \(c\) is mixed with a dearer (costlier) ingredient with unit cost price \(d\) to obtain a mixture with a mean cost price \(m\). Using simple algebra, if \(q_1\) units of the cheaper ingredient and \(q_2\) units of the dearer ingredient are mixed, the total cost is:

$$c \cdot q_1 + d \cdot q_2 = m(q_1 + q_2)$$

Rearranging the terms gives:

$$q_1(m - c) = q_2(d - m)$$

$$\frac{\text{Quantity of Cheaper } (q_1)}{\text{Quantity of Dearer } (q_2)} = \frac{d - m}{m - c}$$

This gives us the golden Rule of Alligation:

$$\frac{\text{Quantity of Cheaper}}{\text{Quantity of Dearer}} = \frac{\text{Cost Price of Dearer } (d) - \text{Mean Price } (m)}{\text{Mean Price } (m) - \text{Cost Price of Cheaper } (c)}$$

In the exam, we represent this visually in a criss-cross diagram to calculate the ratio in seconds:

Cheaper IngredientMean Value (Mixture)Dearer Ingredient
\(c\)\(d\)
\(m\)
\(d - m\):\(m - c\)

Two Golden Rules of the Alligation Diagram:

  • Range Rule: The mean value \(m\) must always lie strictly between the two \textreme values, meaning \(c < m < d\). Subtract the smaller number from the larger number along each diagonal so that both ratio terms remain positive.
  • Same Unit Rule: All three values (\(c\), \(d\), and \(m\)) must be in the exact same unit and same basis. If \(c\) and \(d\) are Cost Prices per kg, then \(m\) must also be the Cost Price per kg (not Selling Price). If \(c\) and \(d\) are percentages of milk, \(m\) must also be the percentage of milk.

4. Finding the Mean Value When the Ratio is Known

Sometimes, the exam question gives you the prices (or averages) \(c\) and \(d\) along with the mixing ratio \(q_1 : q_2\), and asks you to find the mean price \(m\). You can use the weighted average formula directly:

$$m = \frac{c \cdot q_1 + d \cdot q_2}{q_1 + q_2}$$

Shortcut Trick: Find the difference between the two \textreme values \((d - c)\) and divide this difference in the ratio \(q_1 : q_2\). Notice that \(q_1 + q_2\) parts equal \(d - c\). Once you find the value of \(q_1\) parts or \(q_2\) parts, either add \(q_2\) parts to \(c\) or subtract \(q_1\) parts from \(d\) to get \(m\) immediately.

5. Successive Removal and Replacement Formula

This is a favorite question type in RRB NTPC and Group D exams. Suppose a container initially contains \(V\) litres of a pure liquid (say, pure milk). From this container, \(x\) litres of the mixture are drawn out and replaced with \(x\) litres of water. If this operation is performed a total of \(n\) times, then the quantity of pure liquid left in the container after \(n\) operations is given by:

$$\text{Quantity of Pure Liquid Left} = V \left(1 - \frac{x}{V}\right)^n$$

From this formula, we can also directly find the ratio of pure liquid left to the total volume of the mixture:

$$\frac{\text{Pure Liquid Left}}{\text{Total Volume } (V)} = \left(1 - \frac{x}{V}\right)^n$$

And the quantity of water (the replacing liquid) in the final mixture is simply:

$$\text{Water in Final Mixture} = V - \text{Pure Liquid Left}$$

Variation with Unequal Replacements: What if different quantities \(x_1, x_2, x_3\) are drawn out and replaced with water in the 1st, 2nd, and 3rd operations respectively? In that case, the formula adapts effortlessly:

$$\text{Pure Liquid Left} = V \left(1 - \frac{x_1}{V}\right)\left(1 - \frac{x_2}{V}\right)\left(1 - \frac{x_3}{V}\right)$$

6. Dishonest Milkman Concept (Zero-Cost Water Mixing)

In RRB exams, you will frequently see questions about a milkman mixing water into pure milk. Unless stated otherwise, the cost price of water is always taken as Rs. 0 per litre.

  • Case A (Selling at Cost Price): If a milkman mixes water with pure milk and sells the mixture at the Cost Price of pure milk to gain \(P\%\) profit, then the profit comes entirely from the free water added. Hence, the ratio of water to milk is directly:

    $$\frac{\text{Water}}{\text{Milk}} = \frac{P}{100}$$

  • Case B (Selling at a Different Price): If pure milk costs \(C\) per litre and the milkman sells the mixture at \(S\) per litre to earn \(P\%\) profit, first calculate the Mean Cost Price of the mixture using:

    $$\text{Mean CP } (m) = \frac{S \times 100}{100 + P}$$

    Then apply the Alligation rule between Water (Rs. 0) and Pure Milk (Rs. \(C\)) with Mean CP \(m\).

7. Cross-Chapter Applications of Alligation

Understanding what the final ratio represents when Alligation is applied to other chapters is crucial. Use this quick-reference table during your revision:

Chapter / TopicQuantity Placed on Alligation CrossWhat the Final Ratio Represents
Price & MixtureCost Price per kg / litreRatio of Quantities / Weights mixed
Profit & LossProfit % or Loss % (negative)Ratio of Cost Prices of the two items
Simple InterestRate of Interest (% p.a.)Ratio of Principals (Sums) invested
AveragesAverage of Group 1 & Group 2Ratio of Number of Members in each group
Time, Speed & DistanceSpeed (km/h or m/s)Ratio of Time Taken (NOT Distance!)
Solutions / AlloysPercentage or Fraction of one componentRatio of Total Weights / Volumes of solutions

Solved Examples (Step-by-Step)

Let us now apply these concepts to four distinct, high-probability RRB exam problems. Read each step carefully to understand how to structure your rough work during the exam.

Example 1: Mixing Prices with Profit Percentage (CP vs SP Trap)

Question: In what ratio must a shopkeeper mix two varieties of tea costing Rs. 180 per kg and Rs. 240 per kg so that by selling the mixture at Rs. 220 per kg, he earns a profit of 10%?

Step-by-Step Solution:

  • Step 1: Check the units. The prices of the two tea varieties (Rs. 180/kg and Rs. 240/kg) are Cost Prices (CP), whereas Rs. 220/kg is the Selling Price (SP) of the mixture. We cannot put SP directly in the middle of two CPs!
  • Step 2: Find the Mean Cost Price (\(m\)). Since selling at Rs. 220 gives a 10% profit, 110% of Mean CP = Rs. 220.

    $$\text{Mean CP } (m) = \frac{220 \times 100}{110} = \text{Rs. } 200 \text{ per kg}$$

  • Step 3: Apply the Rule of Alligation. Place \(c = 180\), \(d = 240\), and \(m = 200\).

    $$\text{Ratio of Cheaper : Dearer} = (d - m) : (m - c) = (240 - 200) : (200 - 180)$$

    $$\text{Ratio} = 40 : 20 = 2 : 1$$

  • Answer: The shopkeeper must mix the two varieties of tea in the ratio 2 : 1.

Example 2: Mixing Two Compound Mixtures (Ratio of Liquids)

Question: Vessel A contains milk and water in the ratio 4 : 1, and Vessel B contains milk and water in the ratio 3 : 2. In what ratio should the mixtures from Vessel A and Vessel B be mixed so that the resulting mixture has milk and water in the ratio 5 : 3?

Step-by-Step Solution:

  • Step 1: Choose one component (Milk) and express it as a fraction of the total mixture.
    • Fraction of milk in Vessel A = \(\frac{4}{4 + 1} = \frac{4}{5}\)
    • Fraction of milk in Vessel B = \(\frac{3}{3 + 2} = \frac{3}{5}\)
    • Desired fraction of milk in final mixture = \(\frac{5}{5 + 3} = \frac{5}{8}\)
  • Step 2: Apply the Rule of Alligation on the milk fractions. Note that \(\frac{3}{5} < \frac{5}{8} < \frac{4}{5}\).

    $$\text{Ratio of Vessel A : Vessel B} = \left|\frac{3}{5} - \frac{5}{8}\right| : \left|\frac{4}{5} - \frac{5}{8}\right|$$

  • Step 3: Simplify the fractions using the LCM of 5 and 8, which is 40.
    • First term: \(\left|\frac{24 - 25}{40}\right| = \frac{1}{40}\)
    • Second term: \(\left|\frac{32 - 25}{40}\right| = \frac{7}{40}\)
  • Step 4: Cancel the common denominator.

    $$\text{Ratio} = \frac{1}{40} : \frac{7}{40} = 1 : 7$$

  • Answer: The mixtures from Vessel A and Vessel B should be mixed in the ratio 1 : 7.

Alternative Exam Trick: To avoid fractions completely, multiply all three fractions (\(\frac{4}{5}, \frac{3}{5}, \frac{5}{8}\)) by the LCM of their denominators (40). This converts Vessel A to 32, Vessel B to 24, and the Mean to 25. Now apply Alligation on whole numbers: \((25 - 24) : (32 - 25) = 1 : 7\). This saves precious seconds!

Example 3: Successive Removal and Replacement

Question: A drum contains 60 litres of pure milk. 6 litres of milk is taken out and replaced with water. This process is repeated two more times. Find the quantity of milk left in the drum and the final ratio of milk to water.

Step-by-Step Solution:

  • Step 1: Identify the variables carefully.
    • Initial quantity of pure milk (\(V\)) = 60 litres
    • Quantity replaced each time (\(x\)) = 6 litres
    • Number of operations (\(n\)): Notice the wording